Former U.S. president Donald Trump attends his trial for allegedly covering up hush money payments linked to extramarital affairs, at Manhattan Criminal Court in New York City, on May 7.WIN MCNAMEE/Getty Images
With Donald Trump sitting just feet away, Stormy Daniels testified Tuesday at the former president’s hush money trial about a sexual encounter the porn actor says they had in 2006 that resulted in her being paid to keep silent during the presidential race 10 years later.
Jurors appeared riveted as Ms. Daniels offered a detailed and at times graphic account of the encounter Mr. Trump has denied. Mr. Trump stared straight ahead when Ms. Daniels entered the courtroom, later whispering to his lawyers and shaking his head as she testified.
The testimony was by far the most-awaited spectacle in a trial that has toggled between tabloidesque elements and dry record-keeping details. A courtroom appearance by a porn actor who says she had an intimate encounter with a former American president added to the long list of historic firsts in a landmark case laden with claims of sex, payoffs and cover-ups and unfolding as the presumptive Republican nominee makes another bid for the White House.
Ms. Daniels veered into salacious details despite the repeated objections of defence lawyers, who demanded a mistrial over what they said were prejudicial and irrelevant comments.
“This is the kind of testimony that makes it impossible to come back from,” lawyer Todd Blanche said. “How can we come back from this in a way that’s fair to President Trump?”
The judge rejected the request and said defence lawyers should have raised more objections during the testimony. The Trump team later in the day used its opportunity to question Ms. Daniels to paint her as motivated by personal animus and profiting off her claims against Mr. Trump.
“Am I correct that you hate President Trump?” defence lawyer Susan Necheles asked Ms. Daniels.
“Yes,” she acknowledged.
Ms. Daniels’s statements are central to the case because in the final weeks of Mr. Trump’s 2016 Republican presidential campaign, his then-lawyer and personal fixer, Michael Cohen, paid her US$130,000 to keep quiet about what she says was an awkward and unexpected sexual encounter with Mr. Trump in July, 2006, at a celebrity golf outing in Lake Tahoe. Mr. Trump has pleaded not guilty.
Led by a prosecutor’s questioning, Ms. Daniels described how an initial meeting at a golf tournament, where they discussed the adult film industry, progressed to a “brief” sexual encounter that she said Mr. Trump initiated after inviting her to dinner and back to his hotel suite.
She said she didn’t feel physically or verbally threatened, though she knew his bodyguard was outside the suite. There was also what she perceived as an imbalance of power: Mr. Trump “was bigger and blocking the way,” she said.
At the time, Mr. Trump was married to his wife, Melania, who has not been in court for the trial. Ms. Daniels said Mr. Trump told her they did not sleep in the same room, prompting him to shake his head at the defence table.
After it ended, Ms. Daniels said, “It was really hard to get my shoes because my hands were shaking so hard.”
“He said, `Oh, it was great. Let’s get together again, honey bunch,”' Ms. Daniels said. “I just wanted to leave.”
Porn star Stormy Daniels described her 2006 encounter with Donald Trump in unflattering terms at his criminal trial on May 7, testifying she tried not to think about the sex while it took place and feared it would become public.
Reuters
In the years since the encounter was disclosed, Ms. Daniels has emerged as a vocal Trump antagonist, sharing her story innumerable times and criticizing the former president with mocking and pejorative jabs. But there was no precedent for Tuesday’s testimony, when she came face-to-face with Mr. Trump and was asked under oath in an austere courtroom to describe her experiences to a jury weighing whether to convict a former American president of felony crimes for the first time in history.
She told jurors how she met Mr. Trump because the adult film studio she worked for at the time sponsored one of the holes on the golf course. She said they had a brief conversation when Mr. Trump’s group passed through, chatting about the adult film industry and her directing abilities. The celebrity real estate developer remarked that she must be “the smart one” if she was making films, Ms. Daniels recalled.
Later, in an area known as the “gift room,” where celebrity golfers collected gift bags and swag, Mr. Trump remembered her as “the smart one” and asked her to dinner, Ms. Daniels said.
She said her then-publicist suggested in a phone call that Mr. Trump’s invitation was a good excuse to skip a work dinner and would “make a great story” and perhaps help her career.
“What could possibly go wrong?” she recalled the publicist saying.
The two saw each other periodically in the ensuing years, when she said she spurned Mr. Trump’s advances.
In 2011, several years after she and Mr. Trump were last in touch, she said she learned from her agent that the story of her encounter with Mr. Trump had made its way to a magazine.
She said she agreed to an interview for US$15,000 because “I’d rather make the money than somebody make money off of me, and at least I could control the narrative.” The story never ran, but later that year, she was alarmed when an item turned up on a website.
Perhaps seeking to pre-empt defence claims that she was in urgent need of a massive payout, Ms. Daniels testified that she was in the best financial shape of her life when she authorized her manager to shop her story during the 2016 presidential campaign.
She said she had no intent of approaching Mr. Cohen or Mr. Trump to have them pay her.
“My motivation wasn’t money,” she said. “It was to get the story out,” she testified.
But Ms. Necheles zeroed in on that point, pressing Ms. Daniels on the fact that she owes Mr. Trump hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees stemming from an unsuccessful defamation lawsuit and that she tweeted in 2022 that she “will go to jail before I pay a penny.”
“That was me saying, `I will not pay for telling the truth,”' Ms. Daniels testified Tuesday.
She later forcefully denied that she was trying to squeeze Mr. Trump for money.
“You were looking to extort money from President Trump,” Ms. Necheles said.
“False,” Ms. Daniels responded.
“Well, that’s what you did,” the lawyer said.
“False,” Ms. Daniels answered.
Ms. Daniels was expected to return to the witness stand Thursday, when the trial resumes.
Testimony so far has made clear that at the time of the payment to Ms. Daniels, Mr. Trump and his campaign were reeling from the October, 2016, publication of the never-before-seen 2005 Access Hollywood footage in which he boasted about grabbing women’s genitals without their permission.
Before that video was made public, “there was very little if any interest” in Ms. Daniels’s claims, according to testimony earlier in the trial from her then-lawyer, Keith Davidson. A deal was reached with the National Enquirer for Ms. Daniels’s story, but the tabloid backed out. Mr. Davidson began negotiating with Mr. Cohen directly, hiked up the price to US$130,000, and reached a deal.
After the deadline for the US$130,000 payment from Mr. Cohen came and went, she authorized Mr. Davidson to cancel the deal. He did, by e-mail, according to documents shown in court. But about two weeks later, the deal was revived.
Ms. Daniels testified that she ended up with about US$96,000 of the US$130,000 payment, after her lawyer and agent got their cuts.
She also said she was steadfast in abiding by her non-disclosure agreement with Mr. Cohen, declining to comment to The Wall Street Journal for a November, 2016, story that reported she had been in discussions to tell her story on Good Morning America but that nothing had come of it. She also declined to comment for the newspaper before it broke the news of her hush money arrangement in 2018.
After that story was published, her life turned into “chaos,” she testified.
“I was front and foremost everywhere,” she recalled.
Prosecutors are building toward their star witness, Mr. Cohen, who pleaded guilty to federal charges related to the hush money payments.
Mr. Trump is charged with 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in connection with the payments. The trial is the first of his four criminal cases to reach a jury.